Thursday, November 13, 2008

The Odyssey, Bk 5: Odysseus-Nymph and Shipwreck

The Odyssey Now Dawn arose from her couch from beside lordly Tithonus

Tithonus, that's not a mythic name you hear very often. Poor Tithonus...he was granted immortality but not perpetual youth.

Once again Athena speaks to the other gods, especially Zeus. "Daddy, daddy, can we get Odysseus home now. You said! And Telemachus is in danger! We have to do something!

"My child," Zeus who marshalls the thunderheads replied,
"what nonsense you let slip through your teeth. Come now,
wasn't the plan your own? You conceived it yourself:
Odysseus shall return and pay the traitors back.
Telemachus? Sail him home iwth all your skill--(24-28)
So Hermes takes the message to Calypso, who complies. She gives Odysseus the tools he needs, he creates his raft, and he packs his bags and leaves. But not before the two had a little good-bye sex. Natch.

Ruh roh, again.
But now Poseidon, god of the earthquake, saw him--
just returning home from his Ethiopian friends,
from miles away on the Solymi mountain-range
he spied Odysseus sailing down the sea
and it made his fury boil even more. (309-313)
Calmus' daughter Ino advises Odysseus to strip and wear her scarf and leave the wreckage of his raft behind. At first he doesn't but then he must. When he reaches shore he is to throw it back without looking back. He does so, but not before several cliffhanger moments of sea surges and rugged reefs.
Struggling up from the banks, he flung himself
in the deep reeds, he kissed the good green earth
and addressed his fighting spirit, deperate still (512-514)
Shore? Woods? Cold wind? Wild beasts? He chooses wild beasts, and finds a sheltered spot with leaves to cover himself.

The Big Read IV: Shirley Jackson's "Afternoon in Linen"

The Lottery: And Other StoriesAfternoon in Linen

Everyone is in linen. It all sounds very crisp. I think the moment in which the character shifts is right at the beginning when she thinks of Alice.

Like in Alice Through the Looking-Glass, the little girl thought, looking at her grandmother; like the gentleman all dressed in white paper. I'm a gentleman all dressed in pink paper, she thought.
When Alice enters that other world, she must think like a survivor. She must act from the hidden cues, not the obvious ones. This little girl must now act in a way that will horrify her grandmother, because there are other matters to think about than those her grandmother has in mind.

At first she thinks she'll refuse to play the piano just because. That sends her further into the other-rational world of Alice. She must have a reason for not playing. She contradicts her grandmother at every turn. "I don't know any," the little girl said. Then it becomes about saving face in the schoolyard...the boy Harold will tell they other kids she writes poetry. She can't have that.

She still can't avoid the poetry...her grandmother has it in an envelope, and even has the boy fetch it. He laughs and gloats. Harriet is backed into a corner.
He'll tell all the kids on the block, Harriet though. "I didn't write it," she said.
"Why, Harriet!" Her grandmother laughed. "You don't need to be so modest, child. You write very nice poems."
"I copied it out of a book," Harriet said. "I found it in a book and I copied it and gave it to my old grandmother and said I wrote it."
Three times Harriet must say she copied the poems. Now it might even be about impressing the other kids.
Harriet looked at Howard, who was staring at her in admiration. "I copied it out of a book," she said to him. "I found the book in the library one day."
Oh her poor poor grandmother.

This just leaves me sad. Her poor grandmother thinking her granddaughter has been deliberately deceiving her.

Read what others have to say here.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

The Odyssey, Bk 4: The King and Queen of Sparta

The Odyssey At last they gained the ravines of Lacedaemon

Telemachus and Nestor's son Pisistratus arrive during wedding festivities. Menelaus says "Wait, don't tell me. You must be the sons of kings. I'm right, aren't I."

Unbidden Menelaus speaks of Odysseus.

for none of all those comrades, pained as I am,
do I grieve as much for one...
that man who makes sleep hateful, even food,
as I pore over his memory. No one, no Achaean
labored hard as Odysseus labored or achieved so much. (116-120)
Menelaus realizes T is Odysseus' son, but ponders whether to grill him. Why do that? But Helen, of the launched a thousand ships fame, steals his thunder.
"Right or wrong, what can I say? My heart tells me
to come right out and say I've never seen such a likeness,
neither in man nor woman--I'm amazed at the sight.
To the life he's like the son of great Odysseus,
surely he's Telemachus!" (155-159)
Helen goes on...
The boy that hero left
a babe in arms at home when all you Achaeans
fought at Troy, launching your headlong battles
just for my sake, shameless whore that I was." (159-162)
I seem to recall her doing this in the Iliad as well. She seems to require it of herself, call herself a shameless whore. That bit goes by unremarked upon, as though it's just part of the background noise, she says it so often. I also get this image of two embittered people, staying together for propriety, with barely veiled hostile remarks flying back and forth across the dinner table. I could so see this in a contemporary movie, the unhappy rich couple spatting incessantly, finding small ways to manipulate the other, 'for the other's own good' of course.

Like here:
Then Zeus's daughter Helen thought of something else,
Into the mixing-bowl from which they drank their wine
she slipped a drug, heart's-ease, dissolving anger,
magic to make us all forget our pains...
No one who drank it deeply, mulled in wine,
could let a tear roll down his cheeks that day. (243-248)
Can't have this war-induced grief bringing down a wedding party, can we?

Helen recounts a story of helping Odysseus when he entered the city as a beggar spy. Menelaus snarks back about her knocking on the wooden horse, hoping to get those hidden inside to betray themselves.
Three times you sauntered round our hollow ambush,
feeling, stroking its flanks,
challenging all our fighters, calling each by name-- (310-312)
Menelaus recounts his way home--how he held The Old Man of the Sea, who then had to tell him the truth. Menelaus gets to go home, the Old Man tells him, because he's the son-in-law of Zeus. So that's why the rich couple stays together: she's the one with the 'money' or 'connections'; he's the one with respectability. An unhappy match, that. The Old Man also tells him of Odysseus' being held by Calypso.

Ruh roh:
But lord Antinous sat apart,
dashing Eurymachus beside him, ringleaders,
head and shoulders the strongest of the lot.
Phronius' son Noemon approached them now,
quick to press Antinous with a question:
"Antinous, have we any notion or not
when Telemachus will return from sandy Pylos?
He sailed in a ship of mine and now I need her back..." (706-713)
Penelope discovers T's absence. She prays to Pallas, who sends a phantom with a dispatch to ease her pain. Of course she can't help but ask about Odysseus. The phantom's response:
"I cannot tell you the story start to finish,
whether he's dead or alive,
It's wrong to lead you on with idle words." (940-942)
Why idle words? So the bards can have a story to tell?

The Big Read IV: Shirley Jackson's "Charles"

The Lottery: And Other Stories Gail G shared this article from Salon back in '97 about Shirley Jackson. I look forward to reading it.

Charles (read it here)

How does the act of going to school change a child even before he gets there? Where did this come from?

I knew immediately the darling Laurie was actually 'Charles.' He'd already been displaying the same behavior, which baffled his parents, but it never occurred to them he would create a persona who did all the actions he actually did. I could see that he might learn this behavior from someone else at school, but how did we get the "sweet-voiced nursery-school tot replaced by a long-trousered, swaggering character who forgot to stop at the corner and wave goodbye"? Perhaps there was a Mr. Harris character that came along and gave him ideas before story started.

I suppose, as a smart boy, he realized it was wrong to 'be fresh,' so when his mother questioned him, he quickly thought up Charles so it wouldn't be him, Laurie, who was the bad one.

"What did he do?" I asked. "Who was it?"
Laurie thought. "It was Charles," he said. "He was fresh. The teacher spanked him and made him stand in a corner. He was awfully fresh."
It's funny how he covers up his having to stay after school for being so bad.
"Charles yelled so in school they sent a boy in from first grade to tell the teacher she had to make Charles keep quiet, and so Charles had to stay after school. And so all the children stayed to watch him."
Of course mom misses the first Parent-Teacher meeting. The parents inadvertently encourage their son to act out as Charles, so they can have more stories.

I appreciate the ending. And I don't appreciate the ending. I want to read about mom's reaction as she realizes her son is Charles. I want something like the ending of The Renegade. Still, it's good for a gotcha, if you didn't get it early on about Laurie/Charles. I'm still mystified about where he got the acting out from. Perhaps that is on purpose...we the reader are supposed to be as clueless as the parents?

Read what others have to say here.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

The Odyssey, Bk 3: King Nestor Remembers

The Odyssey ...the people lined the beaches, sacrificing sleek black bulls to Poseidon

Athena in disguise makes an offering and prays to Poseidon. What happens when a goddess is acting behind another god's back, and she prays to that god? Apparently it doesn't get attention, not yet anyway.

[Agamemnon] meant to detain us there and offer victims,
anything to appease Athena's dreadful wrath-- (160-161)
I wonder if that was his daughter that Aggie wished to sacrifice? According to Aeschylus, his wife kills him for it. According to Nestor in Homer, his son did so:
But Atreus' son Agamemnon...you yourselves, even
in far-off Ithaca, must have heard how he returned,
how Aegisthus hatched the king's horrendous death. (218-220)
Nestor knows nothing of Odysseus. He says,
"Still I advise you to visit Menelaus.
He's back from abroad at last, from people so removed
you might abandon hope of ever returning home,
once the winds had driven you that far off course...
So, off you go with your ships and shipmates now.
Or if you'd rather go by land, there's team and chariot,
my sons at your service too..." (358-366)
So Athena echoes:
"...But you, seeing my friend is now your guest,
speed him on his way with a chariot and your son
and give him the finest horses that you have,
bred for stamina, trained to race the wind."
With that the bright-eyed goddess winged away
in an eagle's form and flight.
Amazement fell on all the Achaeans there. (411-417)
There's no refusing a goddess. The next day Nestor leads the choreography of a slaughter in offering. Homer makes this ritual killing sound so glamorous, but despite the gold-wrapped horns I bet it's grubby and messy and blood spatters their clean clothes. On the other hand, this must be a handsome sight:
During the ritual lovely Polycaste, youngest daughter
of Nestor, Neleus' son, had bathed Telemachus.
Rinsing him off now, rubbing him down with oil,
she drew a shirt and handsome cape around hime.
Out of his bath he stepped, glistening like a god,
strode in and sat by the old commander Nestor. (521-526)
Telemachus and Nestor's son Pisistratus ride on.

The Big Read IV: Shirley Jackson's "After You, My Dear Alphonse"

The Lottery: And Other Stories The Lottery and Other Stories by Shirley Jackson

After You, My Dear Alphonse (read it here)

I was curious about the title. Was it a common cultural use? Apparently so. According to this resource, it "originated with a comic strip that first appeared in 1905. The expression is generally used when two people go back and forth, suggesting the other go first, as a way of being polite."

I know I've read this story before as well.

Here's another case in which the children exist in a world that's completely inaccessible to the adult. The two are simply playing, trading the saying, carting props around, and looking for dinner. Mom, on the other hand, assumes her child ordered Boyd, the Negro boy, to haul wood, assumes Boyd would need hand-me-down clothes, and didn't feel she could assume Boyd's father held a job. When Boyd has "plenty of clothes, thank you." Mrs. Wilson thinks him ungrateful and is angry, or rather, disappointed. He hasn't fulfilled her image of a Negro boy.

Again the ending completes the separation between the children and the adult:

"Is your mother still mad?" Mrs. Wilson heard Boyd ask in a low voice.
"I don't know," Johnny said. "She's screwy sometimes."
"So's mine," Boyd said. He hesitated. "After you, my dear Alphonse."